Tuesday 4 July 2017

Into the Water by Paula Hawkins

The much-anticipated second novel by the author of The Girl on the Train. It must be difficult to write after your first novel was wildly successful, a best seller, and made into a movie. But then again, who wouldn't (even secretly) want that for their first novel? So surely you should anticipate it - even just a little, and have a book up your sleeve that's a bit like the first. This isn't.

Lena is the teenage girl left alone after her mother - Nel's - body is found at the bottom of a river that runs near town. Nel's sister Jules who she doesn't know, must now raise her. 

There are more people - the detectives, and their families; Lena's friends from school and their parents; the teachers and the principal and all the other usual characters you meet in a small town. In the background looms the town's shadowy watery history - the other women who have had their lives end in the depths of gloom and despair. Are the stories of their deaths accurate? Or was there more to it all?

There was a lot of story and character building, which I didn't mind. There were also a number of points of view - also ok. The tension? Mild, but there, and a steady increase through the pages. I did enjoy the sense of place that Paula Hawkins created - the setting - small town, woodland cottage and river scenery was vividly drawn.

It all felt rather contrived by the end. The author needed enough characters to keep us guessing who murdered, and how. In my view, this muddied the waters too much.  The plot, as it unfolded, was satisfying, and I enjoyed the hours I spent reading this book.

3 stars
ISBN: 9780735211209

You may also enjoy Dead Woman Walking by Sharon Bolton or Black-Eyed Susans by Julia Heaberlin.

More Books


Elza Reads said...

Girl on the Train grabbed my attention immediately, with Into the Water, I don't mind putting it down and go do something else. It is well written and I love the "history" of the women in the water. This would actually make a better movie than Girl on the Train. Setting and flashbacks will make a nice movie I think.

Will let you know when I'm done with it!

Maria said...

I totally loved it. I was already looking for this kind of books after I had read "The Girl On the Train". She totally placed the story so well. The dark current of waters. The single mother. Totally full of suspense.